How to set a tolerance band for structural steel vs. curtain wall

Why one tolerance band doesn't work for both trades
Steel erectors work in inches, and generous ones. AISC's Code of Standard Practice sets plumbness tolerances for a column line at roughly 1:500, with individual member tolerances layered on top of that. A multi-story frame can be out by close to an inch over its height and still be a compliant erection. That number isn't sloppy. Steel is meant to take up slack: it's erected with field bolts that allow adjustment, it settles under dead load as floors get poured, and the connection design assumes some of that movement before anyone calls it a problem.
Curtain wall doesn't get that slack. A glazing contractor is typically holding flatness to something like 1/4 inch in 20 feet, and reveal consistency across an elevation can be tighter still, because any variance shows up visually the moment the sun hits the panel line. The wall system also has to go up against steel that's already sitting inside its own tolerance band, so the glazing crew is chasing a surface that was allowed to be off before they ever set an anchor.
Run both trades through the same deviation threshold in a point cloud comparison and you get one of two bad outcomes. Set the band loose enough for steel and you'll miss curtain wall misalignment until the glazing crew calls it in themselves, usually after panels are cut. Set it tight enough for curtain wall and every normal, code-compliant steel connection lights up as a flag, and the superintendent stops trusting the report.
Setting the band by trade, not by project
The fix is to stop treating tolerance as one number for the whole job and assign it by element type instead.
- Structural steel: tie the band to the applicable AISC tolerance for the member type, not a flat inch-and-a-half rule of thumb. A beam has a different allowable deviation than a column baseplate elevation.
- Curtain wall and glazing: pull the tolerance from the project's glazing spec or AAMA reference, which will almost always be tighter than the steel band underneath it, and apply it per plane or per joint rather than per floor.
- Everything else on the model: MEP hangers, embeds, slab edges, each gets its own band pulled straight from spec, matched to its own element class.
This is a QA decision, not a software setting. Someone on the BIM team has to go through the spec sections and assign the right number to the right element class before a comparison report means anything. Skip that step and the report will either bury you in false positives or quietly pass over the deviation that costs real money to fix after drywall is up.
What this looks like on a monthly as-built pass
Once the bands are set per trade, a monthly registration of the site surface against the design model gives you a flag list sorted by element type instead of one undifferentiated pile of red dots. Steel out of its AISC band on a column line is a different conversation, at a different urgency, than a curtain wall mullion out of its glazing tolerance on the same floor.
That's the gap As-Built Compare is built to close. Instead of waiting for the closeout survey to find out a curtain wall anchor was set against a column that was already out of plumb, a monthly drone-captured comparison against the design model catches it while the steel is still accessible and the glazing hasn't been fabricated to fit the wrong surface.
If your team is still eyeballing deviation off a single tolerance number for every trade on the model, it's worth getting steel and curtain wall onto separate bands before the next pour locks the frame in place. As-Built Compare is running that comparison as an early-access pilot now, and we're looking for project teams willing to try it on a live job.